Cookie Profile
Flavor: Salted Peanut Butter Cookie
Ingredients: Peanut butter, light brown sugar, eggs, vanilla extract, sea salt
Price: $3.5
Calories: 150-250 Calories
Three-word Review: Peanut Butter Bombshell
Score: 8.7
About: Ovenly
Owners Agatha Kulaga and Erin Patinkin left their college degrees and 9-5 jobs behind to follow their passion for baking. They met at a food-focused book club and the rest is history. Their recipes come from Erin’s grandmother’s rich baking history and Agatha’s upbringing. Combined you’re getting rich, historic recipes that have been passed down and perfected. Two fantastic cookies that you’ll find at Ovenly are the Salted Peanut Butter and the Salted Chocolate Chip (secretly vegan).
Chef's Note
Ovenly uses high-quality ingredients for all of their goods. They use, and highly recommend, Wuthrich butter (83% European Style Butter), King Arthur flour, cocoa and chocolate chips from Callebaut and locally sourced ingredients from small farms.
Ovenly has a variety of baked goods that appeal to both vegans and non-vegans. You’ll find they put a little more of an emphasis on vegan treats and gluten-free treats than most bakeries.
What also makes them unique is that they tend to use a balance of sweet and salty in a lot of their creations. In addition, they also offer a variety of artisanal coffees inside their bakeshops which is unique in the industry.
Experience
Whenever you visit any of the Ovenly locations you are always treated like you are part of the neighborhood bakery. The bakeries are always clean and the staff is very warm, welcoming and helpful. They are a staple of New York City who are loved by locals and tourists alike.
Review
Appearance
The Salted Peanut Butter Cookie is golden in color with ripples of dough on the surface. The cookie is small in size but fairly thick.
Touch
The cookie is dense with decent weight. Just by holding it you can tell it has nice volume will be mightier than its size. The surface is fairly smooth.
Smell
Peanut butter dominates the smell of the cookie. It tickles your peanut butter spidey-sense.
Taste
The first bite is heavy and full of peanut butter goodness. It’s smooth and delicious but not too sweet. The texture is doughy and moist, which goes great with superb peanut butter flavor. The Salted Peanut Butter Cookie is one of Ovenly’s top sellers and one that is a hit for any peanut butter lover. It’s also worth noting that it’s gluten-free and dairy-free.
What to Tell Your Friends
A doughy peanut butter delight that packs a ton of flavor inside of a 2.5 inch cookie. It’s a must try on any trip to Ovenly.
Guilt-Free Zone
Burn 150-250 calories
- Walk for 2 miles
- Elliptical for 20 min
- Play golf for 30 min
